Eric Swirsky, JD, MA Director of Graduate Studies Clinical Assistant Professor Ethical Decision-making © 2017 Eric Scott Swirsky Seven Step

Eric Swirsky, JD, MA
Director of Graduate Studies
Clinical Assistant Professor

Ethical Decision-making

© 2017 Eric Scott Swirsky

Seven Step Decision-making Process

1. Identify the type of moral or ethical dilemma
2. Reflect on personal bias or assumptions
3. Gather relevant information
4. Consider stakeholder interests and values
5. Explore practical alternatives
6. Complete and justify the action
7. Evaluate the process and outcome

Case Example

A 24 year-old graduate student develops a severe
headache and a stiff neck and is brought to the ER by a
friend. Physical exam shows a patient with a
temperature of 103°F and a stiff neck. After obtaining
informed consent, a spinal fluid exam reveals cloudy
fluid with a white cell count of 2,000 and with bacteria
suggesting pneumococcal meningitis. Antibiotics are
recommended but the patient refuses. He offers no
reason for his refusal.

Siegler, M. Teaching Clinical Medical Ethics. PowerPoint presentation, MacLean Fellowship 2011-2012.

© 2017 Eric Scott Swirsky

• Moral Distress

• Ethical Dilemma

• Moral Agency

• Locus of Authority

Step One — Identify the Type of Ethical Problem

© 2017 Eric Scott Swirsky

• Gut reaction

• Identify personal assumptions, biases, emotions, and
values

• Conflicting personal and professional values

• Impact on decision-making

Step Two – Reflect on Personal Bias

© 2017 Eric Scott SwirskyStep Three – Gather Info

Medical Indications

The Principles of Beneficence and Nonmaleficence

1. What is the patient’s medical problem? history?
diagnosis? prognosis?

2. Is the problem acute? chronic? critical? emergent?
reversible?

3. What are the goals of treatment?
4. What are the probabilities of success?

Patient Preferences
The Principles of Respect for Autonomy

1. What are the patient’s preferences for treatment?
2. Has the patient been informed of benefits and risks,

understood this information and given consent?
3. Is the patient mentally capable and legally

competent? Is there evidence of incapacity?
4. If incapacitated, who is the appropriate surrogate? Is

the surrogate using appropriate standards for decision
making?

5. Has the patient expressed prior preferences, e.g.,
living will?

Siegler, M. Teaching Clinical Medical Ethics. PowerPoint presentation, MacLean Fellowship 2011-2012.

Quality of Life

The Principles of Beneficence, Nonmaleficence, and
Respect for Autonomy

1. What are the prospects, with or without treatment, for
return to normal life, and with what physical, mental,
and social deficits might the patient experience even if
treatment succeeds?

2. What ethical issues arise concerning improving or
enhancing a patient’s quality of life?

3. Do quality of life assessments raise any questions
regarding changes in treatment plans, such as
foregoing life-sustaining treatment?

Siegler, M. Teaching Clinical Medical Ethics. PowerPoint presentation, MacLean Fellowship 2011-2012.

Contextual Features

1. Are there family issues that might influence
treatment decisions?

2. Are there financial and economic factors?

3. Are there religious or cultural factors?

4. Are there limits to confidentiality?

5. How does the law affect treatment decisions?

6. Is clinical research or teaching involved?
Siegler, M. Teaching Clinical Medical Ethics. PowerPoint presentation, MacLean Fellowship 2011-2012.

© 2017 Eric Scott Swirsky

• Which parties have an interest in the process?

• Which parties have an interest in the outcome?

• Who is directly involved in the case?

• Who is indirectly involved?

Step Four – Consider Stakeholder Interests and Values

© 2017 Eric Scott Swirsky

• Doing nothing

• Time limited trials

• Be creative

• Respecting confidentiality

Step Five – Explore Practical Alternatives

© 2017 Eric Scott Swirsky

The goal of analysis is to determine the range of
ethically acceptable options and take action.

Use ethical theories or approaches to justify action

Step Six – Complete the Action

© 2017 Eric Scott Swirsky

• What went well, and why do you think so?

• Most challenging aspects? Compare to other
situations? What future applications?

• Who helped most? Feedback from patient, family,
care team, others?

• What did you learn? What would you do differently?

Step Seven – Evaluate the Process and Outcome

Case Example

A 24 year-old graduate student develops a severe
headache and a stiff neck and is brought to the ER by a
friend. Physical exam shows a patient with a
temperature of 103°F and a stiff neck. After obtaining
informed consent, a spinal fluid exam reveals cloudy
fluid with a white cell count of 2,000 and with bacteria
suggesting pneumococcal meningitis. Antibiotics are
recommended but the patient refuses. He offers no
reason for his refusal.

Siegler, M. Teaching Clinical Medical Ethics. PowerPoint presentation, MacLean Fellowship 2011-2012.

  • Ethical Decision-making
  • Seven Step Decision-making Process
  • Case Example
  • Step One — Identify the Type of Ethical Problem
  • Step Two – Reflect on Personal Bias
  • Step Three – Gather Info
  • Medical Indications
  • Patient Preferences
  • Quality of Life
  • Contextual Features
  • Step Four – Consider Stakeholder Interests and Values
  • Step Five – Explore Practical Alternatives
  • Step Six – Complete the Action
  • Step Seven – Evaluate the Process and Outcome
  • Case Example
  • 1. Gather Information
  • 2. Identify the Type of Ethical Problem
  • 3. Use Ethical Theories to Analyze the Problem
  • 4. Explore the alternatives
  • ��5. Complete the action�����6. Evaluate the process and outcome��

Share This Post

Email
WhatsApp
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest
Reddit

Order a Similar Paper and get 15% Discount on your First Order

Related Questions

see attached Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission. Reproduced with permission

see attached Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission. Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission. Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission. Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.

Week 6

In week 8, you will be submitting your research journal.  In this discussion, create and post your outline for that journal, making sure that you use complete sentences for all elements of the outline. Include your thesis statement in the outline in bold font. Remember that, if you have one sub-heading, you should have at least

Kate Chopin

  Kate Chopin In a sense The Awakening is a story about rebellion of a quiet sort, a coming of awareness that compels a young person to seek escape from a social world that can never seem other than a deathtrap. Margaret Fuller heads for Italy and revolution; Huck lights

Literature

ppt/presentation.xml ppt/slideMasters/slideMaster1.xml Click to edit Master title style Click to edit Master text styles Second level Third level Fourth level Fifth level 1/25/2024 ‹#› ppt/slides/slide1.xml The Contendings of Horus and Seth Dr. Carter ppt/slides/slide2.xml The New Kingdom of Ancient Egypt ppt/slides/slide3.xml Nation Building and Empire ppt/slides/slide4.xml Sexual Metaphor in Egyptian

Excel #2

Follow steps Airport Passenger Counts As an analyst for the airline industry, you track the number of passengers at the top six major U.S. airports: Atlanta (ATL), Chicago (ORD), Los Angeles (LAX), Dallas/Fort Worth (DFW), Denver (DEN), and New York (JFK). You researched passenger data and created a worksheet that

Excel

Follow steps SmartPhone Upgrade You have just graduated from college and before beginning your first professional job, you would like to purchase a new smartphone. You have the option to purchase the new phone in one payment or make monthly payments by taking advantage of a 36-month flex payment plan.

Discussion

Please provide a 150 word- response to each discussion post below: 1. At this point in the process there are ironically very few questions and yet so many questions that remain to be answered. For starters I find it difficult to ask questions about the process when I am not

Literature Dissertation Assignment

I will upload the first assignment the assignment speaks of after bid has been accepted. Assignment: Textbook Information: Roberts, C. M., & Hyatt, L. (2019).  The dissertation journey: A practical guide to planning, writing, and defending your dissertation (3rded.). Corwin Publishing Co. ISBN-  9781506373331. Read Chapter 13. This week’s assignment will require